When a friend is struggling, suggesting a new activity comes easily. A series of eight studies suggests that we less often consider reducing existing burdens or harmful habits.
Exercise more, start a hobby, try meditation… In trying to help, we can make the list longer. Do we give equal attention to what someone could reduce?
Study details
Tom J. Barry and Nadia Adelina examined how people give advice about mental health difficulties. Their research, published in Communications Psychology on 20 August 2025, included eight studies of responses to hypothetical people, advice on Reddit and responses from an AI model.
The researchers distinguished between starting something new or doing more, and reducing or stopping an existing behaviour. Overall, the first approach was recommended more often. People tended to judge additive advice as more effective and feasible. The tested GPT-4o model also favoured adding activities.
The pattern was not identical in every setting. In one study, there was no statistically significant difference in the number of additive and subtractive suggestions given to close friends. This does not establish that no difference exists; it suggests that whom we advise may matter.
What was found?
Mental health advice generally favoured new activities. Reducing existing activities was not absent, but it was easier to overlook.
What does it mean?
When trying to help, we might ask not only “What else could you do?” but also “Which burden or habit could be reduced?” This is a possible communication lesson, not a treatment prescription.
Limitations
These were not treatment trials comparing improvements in mental health. The research did not establish that doing less treats depression or anxiety more effectively. Whether additive advice actually makes people feel more overwhelmed also requires further study. Findings from one AI model cannot be generalised to all systems.
Health note
These findings are not a reason to stop medication or psychotherapy. Treatment changes should be discussed with the relevant health professional.
Editor’s Note
A thought I once read in a book has stayed with me: sometimes, when you do not feel like doing anything, perhaps you do not need to push yourself to do something right then. We do not have to keep chasing a goal or fill every spare moment with a task. Sometimes we expect a result from ourselves even while resting.
This study reminded me of that thought. When we want to help someone, instead of immediately suggesting new activities, we can also make room for them to pause and catch their breath. Of course, a persistent loss of motivation that affects daily life should not be dismissed as simply needing rest. But sometimes the permission we can give ourselves is not having to keep up with everything at that moment.
Gürkan Özkoç MD, FACS
Sources
Barry TJ, Adelina N. People overlook subtractive solutions to mental health problems. Communications Psychology. 2025;3:128. DOI: 10.1038/s44271-025-00312-8. Open original article.
Keep this story
Feedback to the editor
Only the editor can read this; it is not a public comment. Do not include personal health information.
Sign in to send feedback